Three C Peanut Butter

Well, two more weeks left of my weird, loop-holey sugar abstinence:

Pros:
No longer randomly grabbing at the meaningless foods in my path:
  • candy bowl proferrings
  • off-brand commercial cookies that don’t taste good anyway
  • dollars in my backpack for the vending machine
  • or that abandoned power bar left temptingly on the bench in the women’s locker room at the gym (embarrassed to admit I even considered it).
  • Slowly peeling away from the “dessert as reward” system of thought
    No longer getting that sugar-binge sweatiness.  I know you know what I mean

    Con:
    I’ve been missing out on the homemade treats of my friends:

  • cheesecake
  • chocolate cheesecake
  • oatmeal cookies
  • pumpkin bread
  • truffles
  • trifle
  • and yes, Ari’s thin mints
  • What I’ve learned:
    This may be the end of wrapped sweets for me, a hard yet liberating decision.  It may also be the end of my own baking…no loss, I was always a mediocre baker.  However, a friend recommended that I make a once-a-week exception for the things made by friends–that I can still appreciate their talents and will probably appreciate the treat for the occasion it represents.
    Weirdly, I’ve had little trouble saying no to most things–except for the Jiffy peanut butter.  Last week I attempted to make my own PB, supplementing spices for the sweetness.  The result?  Definitely not a replacement, but maybe a nice addition to my snacking repertoire.

    Unfortunately, the new method I was hoping I’d be able to share failed.  I realize most students do not have a food processor, so I tried the Simply Recipes method of a mason jar and a blender.  While this was perfect for chopping nuts, it failed utterly in the creaming stage.  I’ll try to put up the 3 part failure video in the near future.
    For now: Roasted peanuts + Chili powder + Cumin + Coriander + Garam masala = the rough-around-the-edges cousin of sweet little Jiffy.

    Ingredients

    • 1.5 cups roasted peanuts
    • 1 tsp cumin
    • 1 tsp coriander
    • 2 tsp chili powder
    • 0.5 tsp garam masala
    • salt to taste…i used about .5 tsp
    • 2 tsp neutral oil (optional) for that glassy effect
    Set the oven to 350F and put the peanuts on a foil-lined baking sheet.  After about 10 minutes, remove the peanuts (they should be warm and easier to break up at this point) and deposit them into a food processor.  Add the spices, salt, and oil, then set the food processor to low, building speed as the peanuts turn into powder.  Keep blending on high, the creaming process will take as much as 10 minutes.  You’ll see the peanuts disintegrate, then clump, then begin to form a particulate ball, and then turn into a paste as the peanuts give up their oil.  Keep blending until you achieve a consistency that you desire.
    Store in the refrigerator for up to 2 weeks.
    This entry was posted in Snacks. Bookmark the permalink.

    11 Responses to Three C Peanut Butter

    1. Vicky says:

      Wow!
      Any reason you couldn’t take ready made peanut butter and just whip the spices in?
      BTW, Whole Foods brand peanut butter in the plastic jar seems like a middle of the road texture/flavor between old fashioned Jiffy, and just ground peanuts or the ones that have all the oil on top, but it’s healthier than Jiffy.
      xo

    2. Becca says:

      That’s 3 of my 4 favorite C’s (the fourth, and probably my favorite, is of course, cinnamon), and I often reference that my draw to a food can be measured in how many of the C’s it has.

      I second the Whole Foods peanut butter, and also Trader Joe’s has good peanut butter plus there is an option for unsalted, which I personally prefer. I don’t miss the sugar or salt, even though I definitely do when I eat the Simply Jif, which is Jif without added sugar or salt. You are supposed to refrigerate them, but I find it gets a little stiff if you do, so i usually don’t, which is okay at the rate that I go through peanut butter.

      Have you ever tried playing with other nut butters? Pre-made peanut butter is actually cheaper than the nuts it takes to make it, but that is not the case for other nut butters. I’ve used homemade cashew butter and almond butter in dressings.

      • Anita says:

        I made a sunflower seed butter a few months ago, and a pistachio butter a few years ago. And I can absent-mindedly finish 2 cups of almond butter in one sitting (there are witnesses), so I try to abstain from that. My life is consumed by making lists of things I can’t eat because I will eat it ALL ;-). I haven’t tried cashew butter yet, I’m interested!

        • Becca says:

          Well, I made nut butters as needed to use as bases for dressings. Right now I’m not eating dairy, but I’m trying to play with fun veggie sauces, so I just made an almond based honey/garlic/lemon sauce for broccoli slaw. They almost make the dressings creamy.

          A friend of mine and I made the cashew butter to mix with soy sauce, sesame oil, lime juice and I think some ginger and garlic as a rice noodle and veggie salad dressing.

          I too try to avoid simply eating these things because it’s so easy to eat too much. It’s why I don’t bake much these days, even bread, because I can’t (read: can but shouldn’t) finish a loaf before it goes bad.

    3. mary says:

      I am all for homemade nut butters and yours sounds really good .Currently however I am hooked on the sunflower butter from Trader Joe’s. I’ll bring you guys a jar.
      Love Ari’s Mom

    4. mary says:

      Forgot to give you cheers for the junk sugar abstinence. Your body thanks you…and yes the sunflower butter has some cane sugar but not sweet at all.

      • Anita says:

        We’ll see how bad the binge is when I go home in a week! I made a sunflower seed butter early on in the life of this blog…it had your maple syrup in it!

    5. Hannah says:

      I have to try making this! I can see myself “accidentally” putting MSG in it… HAHA.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    What is 8 + 14 ?
    Please leave these two fields as-is:
    IMPORTANT! To be able to proceed, you need to solve the following simple math (so we know that you are a human) :-)